Robert Moses Beach
Robert Moses Beach is located on Fire Island, Long Island. It's number one on the list because it will definitely make you feel like you're not in New York City anymore. It's quaint, quiet, and not crowded. Basically, it's a perfect summertime spot. Filled with concession stands, golf courses and waves, this beach has everything you need.
How to get there: Take the LIRR (Montauk) and get off at Bay Shore, Sayvine or Patchogue. Then take the ferry to the island. Enjoy the view!
[photo via @iRob87]