Antica Pesa
Just because you guys are "cool Williamsburg people," it doesn't mean you get to skip a fancy Valentine's Day dinner out. Stay in the neighborhood and hit the Brooklyn offshoot of Michelin-starred Roman restaurant, Antica Pesa, a celebrity-frequented local fave. Three seatings are available (5:30pm, 7:30pm and 9:30pm) and the prix fixe is $90 per person.
Antica Pesa, 115 Berry St, Brooklyn