Vine Street Cafe
Vine Street Cafe is worth the quick ferry ride over to the little town of Shelter Island. With rustic-elegant decor and quality fresh ingredients, this place will exceed your expectations. Their classic bolognese and crispy duck confit are the most popular items on the menu, followed by the homemade profiteroles with hot fudge, and vanilla ice cream. Then again, you can never go wrong with classic spaghetti.
Vine Street Cafe, 41 South Ferry Rd., Shelter Island
[Photo via @bellasprague]